LIT 4334: The Golden Age of Children's Literature

Malnutrition and Imaginary Meals in Alice in Wonderland and Peter Pan

on April 11, 2013 5:47pm

Upon looking for sources for my paper, I stumbled upon an article that talked about how hunger and malnutrition are represented in Alice in Wonderland, as a commentary on the famines of the Victorian era. According to the article, Lewis Carroll included the tiny pieces of food, about the place, to express that Alice is essentially scrounging for her meals. She is lucky to stumble upon something, but is often left looking about for more food to return her to normal. In the Victorian era, there were enormous food shortages, causing the price of food to be raised to an intolerable level. As a result, meals became hard to come by. Considering Lewis Carroll saw this occurring, and experienced it himself, he felt the need to use it as a theme in Alice in Wonderland, and seek a solution for it.
At one point, in the novel, Alice meets the caterpillar, smoking atop a giant mushroom. When leaving, he tells her that one side will make her small, and one side will make her big. Alice then attempts to regain her original size, and upon doing so, realizes the value of the mushroom. From then on, Alice stores the mushroom pieces in her apron, thinking that she can use them as needed. This mushroom is thus Carroll’s solution for Victorian society–to find food in nature.

In Peter and Wendy, the lost boys complain about having to occasionally make believe their dinners. I personally found this to be one of the most pitiable situations in the book, and I was curious as to why J. M. Barrie might have written such scenes. After reading about the high price of food in the Victorian era, I wondered if perhaps Barrie was also making a commentary about the Edwardian era, through Peter and Wendy, by expressing that, due the food shortages, little boys and girls sometimes had to imagine they had meals. The Edwardian era, however, was described as a golden age between the Victorian era and World War I, hence I am led to believe that the food shortages improved. What I did read was about a Poor Law that was implemented, which gave relief funds to unemployed women, but not to unemployed able-bodied males. As a result, if one was married to an unemployed male, one was cut off from funds, as well. Upon reading this, I wondered about the financial situation of the Davies boys, and if the imaginary meals were an idea thought up by Barrie to quell their growling stomachs, rather than that of society as a whole. Children often play make believe, when it comes to tea parties, but in Peter and Wendy there is an obvious expression that these boys are hungry, despite having nothing,

Advertisements

One response to “Malnutrition and Imaginary Meals in Alice in Wonderland and Peter Pan

  1. ahaleyxxx says:

    These are interesting points, but I’m not sure I am convinced by this argument. Neither Carroll, nor the Liddell family, nor the Llewellyn Davies family were lower class. It’s extremely unlikely that these food shortages led to actual hunger for them.
    As for Alice finding small portions, I was always reminded of fairy food or tea parties when she found little cakes or drinks. Remembering that Carroll was telling the story directly to the girls, it makes sense that he would choose cute cakes and little drink bottles instead of balanced meals for the size-changing magic: they’re appealing and fun. The mushroom finally fixes Alice’s size problem, so perhaps this was a subtler adult reminder that healthy food is best. The mushroom as “Carroll’s solution for Victorian society” doesn’t quite make sense. Where else does one find food if not in nature? If this article means literally ‘finding’ food, I doubt Carroll was advocating a raw vegan diet.
    The “Peter and Wendy” segment of this argument is more convincing. The Lost Boys could certainly be interpreted as lower class, so they might be affected by hunger and need a parental figure to provide for them. But again, the Llewellyn Davies family was not a lower class family. Their father did die, but by that time, J.M. Barrie was committed to providing for them. It’s unlikely they ever knew hunger when Barrie was in their lives, he wouldn’t have allowed it.
    Overall, I wish you had linked to the article you’re referencing. It’s difficult to give feedback when I’m not sure which part of this argument is your own, especially important since this is possibly in your paper.
    As an afterthought, the ‘Poor Law’ reminds me of a welfare bill that I read about recently. Tennessee is considering reducing the welfare allowance of families whose children who do poorly in school. It sounds just like this ‘Poor Law:’ let’s take away the benefits of people who are already doing badly! Yikes.
    http://www.knoxnews.com/news/2013/mar/31/bill-tying-student-performance-to-welfare-in/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: